$1.6m lost in Kenya police shoes scam, audit shows

Interior Department might have lost $1.6m while officers had to buy shoes for themselves.

A Kenya police officer keep vigilance at School of Combat Engineering off Isiolo - Marsabit highway during a security meeting. Kenya's Interior Department might have lost atleast Ksh175.9 million ($1.6m) while police officers had to buy shoes for themselves or were stuck with old ones in a situation described by the Auditor-General as “pathetic and unpleasant”. PHOTO FILE | NATION 

IN SUMMARY

  • There were also similar problems in the procurement of motorcycles.

  • The auditor raised concern over purchases based on expired contracts and overpricing, resulting in a loss of Ksh174.6 million ($1.6m).

  • Irregularities in the purchase of shoes were evident right from the stage of procurement of the footwear for the police.

Advertisement

Kenya's Auditor-General has unearthed irregularities in the procurement of shoes for the police, with purchases beyond the approved amount and falsification of some documents.

The Interior Department might have lost atleast Ksh175.9 million ($1.6m) while police officers had to buy shoes for themselves or were stuck with old ones in a situation described by the Auditor-General as “pathetic and unpleasant”.

There were also similar problems in the procurement of motorcycles, with the auditor raising concern over purchases based on expired contracts and overpricing, resulting in a loss of Ksh174.6 million ($1.6m).

The Auditor-General’s report will be scrutinised by the National Assembly’s Public Accounts Committee, with the accounting officer expected to respond to the queries relating to the 2015/2016 financial year.

Procurement

According to the report, tabled in the House on Wednesday, the irregularities in the purchase of shoes were evident right from the stage of procurement of the footwear for the police.

While the ministry’s procurement plan showed that there was an approval to buy 26,500 pairs of shoes, payment vouchers showed that a supplier was paid Ksh267.9 million ($2.5m) for 78,000 pairs.

This means that 51,500 pairs of shoes were bought and Ksh175.9 million ($1.6m) paid in excess of the approved quantities.

Extra shoes

The Auditor-General said when the department’s officials were asked about it, they stated that the purchase of the extra shoes was necessitated by the addition of 10,000 police trainees.

But auditors found that 4,000 trainees were at the Kenya Police Training College in Kiganjo and 2,000 at the General Service Unit.

Shoes for the additional 4,000 trainees at the Administration Police Training College were paid for separately.

Auditors discovered that records for the stores had been forged as one document had different information in April 2016 and May 2017.

When the auditors checked the situation on the ground, using 12 police divisions as a sample, records showed that they ordered 454 pairs of shoes and got 63 pairs while the records in Nairobi showed that 392 pairs were issued.

The Auditor-General concluded that the records in Nairobi were falsified.

While 57 field units had asked for 12,852 pairs of shoes, they were only given 3,763 pairs, meaning there was a shortfall of 9,089 pairs.

Physical check

“A physical check of the condition of shoes being used by the police across the country revealed a pathetic and unpleasant situation as some officers use worn-out shoes while others have opted to buy shoes from various vendors, contrary to dress regulations for police officers,” says the Auditor-General.

He reported that the purchase of motorcycles at a cost Ksh866.2 million ($8.4 million) was not in the ministry’s procurement plan.

The 4,420 motorcycles were then bought based on an expired contract and were overpriced, auditors discovered.

The first 2,420 Chinese-assembled motorcycles were bought at Ksh210,000 ($2,037) each while the lowest bidder had offered them at Ksh161,733 ($1,568).

There was, thus, a loss of Ksh116.8 million ($1,132,960) from the overpricing.

Another 2,000 motorcycles were bought at Ksh179,000 ($1,736) each against an offer of Ksh150,000 ($1,455) by the lowest bidder, resulting in a loss of Ksh58 million ($562,600). This brought the total loss to Ksh174.8 millio ($1,693,812).

More From The East African
This page might use cookies if your analytics vendor requires them. Accept